27 January 2025

Police Requests for Phone PINs and RIPA Authorities: Legal Considerations

The increasing reliance on digital devices in criminal investigations has led to a rise in cases where the police request access to a suspect’s mobile phone PIN or password. Under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (RIPA), authorities can issue notices compelling individuals to disclose this information. Failure to comply can result in prosecution, often leading to significant legal challenges. However, recent cases have demonstrated that these requests are not always lawful and can be successfully challenged in court.

RIPA and Section 49 Notices

Under Section 49 of RIPA, law enforcement agencies have the power to demand access to encrypted data, including mobile phone passcodes. A refusal to provide this information without a reasonable excuse can lead to criminal charges, carrying a maximum sentence of two years’ imprisonment—or five years in cases involving national security or child indecency offences.

For a RIPA notice to be lawfully issued, authorities must satisfy the following criteria:

• The material is likely to be of substantial value to an investigation.

• Access to the material is necessary and proportionate to the investigation.

• A senior officer (usually of Superintendent rank or higher) has authorised the notice.

While these powers can be vital in certain investigations, concerns have been raised about their potential overuse and the need for strict legal oversight.

A Recent Case at Leicester Crown Court

Kally Sahota, a director at Sahota & Sahota Solicitors, recently represented a client at Leicester Crown Court who was charged with failing to provide their phone PIN under Section 49 of RIPA. Following detailed legal arguments, both in written submissions and oral representations to the prosecution, the charges were ultimately dropped.

The case highlighted the importance of challenging the validity of RIPA notices. In this instance, it was successfully argued that the prosecution had not met the necessary legal threshold and that proceeding with the case was not in the public interest. This result serves as a reminder that individuals facing such charges should seek immediate legal advice, as these notices can sometimes be misused or improperly issued.

Defending Against RIPA Charges

There are several legal grounds on which a RIPA charge can be challenged, including:

• Procedural errors: If the notice was not properly served or authorised, it may be defective.

• Proportionality and necessity: If the request was too broad or unjustified, it may not meet legal requirements.

• Reasonable excuse: If an individual is unable to recall their PIN or technically cannot retrieve it, this could form a valid defence.

Defence solicitors play a crucial role in ensuring that these challenges are effectively raised, either pre-charge or at trial.

Key Considerations for Individuals and Legal Practitioners

For individuals facing a RIPA notice, immediate legal assistance is essential. Anyone served with such an order should:

• Avoid making any immediate statements to police before consulting a solicitor.

• Request full disclosure on why the notice has been issued and whether it meets the legal criteria.

• Challenge the request if there are concerns about its necessity or proportionality.

For legal practitioners, early pre-charge representations can be an effective strategy in persuading the prosecution to discontinue weak cases before they reach court.

Conclusion

The law surrounding phone PIN disclosure remains a complex and evolving area. While law enforcement agencies argue that these powers are essential for tackling crime, there must be strict scrutiny to ensure that such requests are lawful, proportionate, and justified. The recent Leicester Crown Court case demonstrates that when properly challenged, charges for failing to disclose a PIN can be successfully defended.

Sahota & Sahota Solicitors continues to provide expert legal representation in cases involving RIPA, criminal defence, and digital investigations, ensuring that clients’ rights are fully protected.

How Can Sahota & Sahota Solicitors Help?

At Sahota & Sahota Solicitors, we specialise in providing expert legal advice and representation for clients facing criminal charges. Our experienced legal team of specialist criminal defence lawyers will ensure your case is handled professionally and with the utmost care, protecting your rights and working towards the best possible outcome.

If you need advice or representation in a criminal matter, contact Sahota & Sahota Solicitors today.

If you need expert advice do not hesitate to contact us on 0116 255 5155. Our phone lines are open 24 hours a day seven days a week.

Enquiry Form

× How can we help?